I am a grammarholic.
Pheeeeeew. Acknowledged, accepted, released into the ether, and stated in print.
I am blessed with an excellent editor/sponsor Reba, who does talk me down from grammatical edge when I lose my centre over their/there/they’re and other homophones; comma splices; subject-verb agreement errors; and those dangling or misplaced modifiers, to name but a few.
This chronic syntactic disorder does manifest in bizarre ways: I am overly displeased and overjoyed by the quality of all written communication I receive—missives, emails, texts, a message in a bottle, even Post-it notes. And if you’re going to write a note in the sand—make it grammatically correct. Lo! I will notice any error before the swash removes the folly etched upon the shore.
It’s no coincidence that my closest friends all display competent grammatical skills. Roger is quite the martinet, demanding and displaying the highest standard. Someone needs to hold the line. And a tip of the Jacaru to Fotis, a master of the semicolon; especially in his texts.
A recent example: “No plans; but I can help prepare.”
Ahhh. Warms the cockles of my heart.
And lastly my mate Mark, who writes so eloquently a train of thought, clickity-clack, clickity-clack—line after line, paragraph after paragraph, page after page within the correct confines of the rules of grammar.
As part of my 12-step program, I am currently working on Step 8: “Made a list of all persons we had harmed and became willing to make amends to them all.”
Atop that list is the Pied Piper of Folk Rock: Mr. Bob Dylan. “Harmed?” Certainly not physically. If anything benefitted, at least economically, by my purchasing his music (one of the earliest vinyl albums I bought as a teenager was John Wesley Harding). But mea culpa, mea culpa, mea culpa harmed—that is, mentally criticized.
Those aware of his work, especially those with a grammatical bent, know I am referring to the song “Lay, Lady, Lay.” It first appeared on Dylan’s ninth studio album, Nashville Skyline, released by Columbia Records on April 9, 1969.
Grammar nerds—grab your Weedwackers. We’re going to get deep into the brambles. The error is the confusion between verbs lay (transitive) and lie (intransitive). The line is “Lay, lady, lay, lay across my big brass bed.” Lay is a transitive verb that requires a direct object. For example: you lay something down. There must be a direct object receiving the action. Lay the book down.
On the other hand, lie is an intransitive verb that requires no direct object. I lie down. Go lie down. She lies across the bed.
The correct lyric should be: “Lie, lady, lie, lie across my big brass bed.”
Of course, at this point, all my lady readers have bolted from the blog, screeching like banshees at my dull discourse.
Je suis d’accord, ma chère, je suis d’accord.
And now to purge the remaining readership; another Dylan poetic aberration.
Let’s visit Bob Dylan’s second studio album, The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, released by Columbia Records on May 27, 1963. The song is “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright.” With his iconic fingerpicking style, Mr. Dylan sings:
It ain’t no use in turnin’ on your light, babe,
That light I never knowed.
An’ it ain’t no use in turnin’ on your light, babe,
I’m on the dark side of the road.
Grammatically, it should be: “That light I never knew.” Know is an irregular verb. The simple past tense is knew. But knew does not rhyme with road. “Knowed” gives Dylan the sound, meter, dialect, and folk-song character he wants. More importantly, this word choice is deliberate nonstandard usage rather than Dylan not knowing the past tense of know.
Yawn.
Okay, okay; don’t protest twice, it’s alright.
My beloved, straight-shooting sister Kim would put it another way: “Rules are made to be broken.” And we’ve all done that!
But for the artists—whatever their genre—those blessed with a muse, I would substitute “broken” for “transcended.” They have worked at and mastered the rules of their craft and then transcended them. They are the Parnassians with poetic license, and I consider Bob Dylan a lifelong dues-paid member.
And you, mate, where are you on that spectrum?
I don’t knowed.
© 2026 Stephen J. Groak. All rights reserved.

